The usual maintenance scorecard
Traditionally, maintenance reporting covers close rate, open work orders, time to complete, make readies on site that are overdue, average days to make ready, and maybe resident satisfaction.
In AppFolio's 2026 Renter Preferences Report, a survey of 3,002 U.S. renters taken from January 26 to February 4, 2026, 56 percent of residents satisfied with maintenance planned to renew, compared with 31 percent of residents who weren't. AppFolio also found 79 percent of satisfied residents had their issues resolved within a few days or less, while 53 percent of unsatisfied residents waited weeks or more.
Residents satisfied vs. unsatisfied with maintenance
Swipe to see all lines.
| Category | Satisfied with maintenance | Not satisfied with maintenance |
|---|---|---|
| Planning to renew | 56% | 31% |
| Planning to move in the next 12 months | 44% | 69% |
| Likely to recommend their property manager | 83% | 28% |
Start with time to first contact
Time to complete is OK, but time to first contact is a better initial metric. Residents may schedule work around their own day or their animals, which makes time to complete partly out of your control, while time to first contact is something the team controls.
First-time fix rate and repeat work orders
First-time fix rate is a good metric, and repeat work orders grouped by category are a must, because they can show you trends in a unit, potentially harmful residents, and property-wide trends when you look at them at a macro level.
We had a client who saw an increase in leaks on exterior walls every spring. During a property inspection, we found the window weep holes were all clogged. The property backed up to a nature preserve, and sticky aphids from the hackberry trees mixed with pollen and blocked the weep holes, so when it rained heavily in the spring, the walls leaked.
Open work orders can point to a particular resident or to a problem with the unit. As an industry, we've gotten better about not jumping to blame the resident. Blaming the resident still happens and is sometimes valid, but we should always assume good intent.
Don't grade your team on numbers they can't control
The most common mistake I see is using metrics the team can't control to measure staff productivity, and that can be detrimental to morale.
If you base someone's job on a metric, they'll create a positive metric without necessarily doing a good job, because a good metric has become the job. There's a saying in the data world that applies to maintenance too: "Show me a metric that is how you measure the employee, and I'll show you an unreliable metric."
Targets depend on the property
Targets are based more on the staffing and the type of property. A high-rise maintenance team can accomplish more than a garden-style team, but I'd expect a slightly longer turn time on high-rise units that have a higher grade of turn quality.
Reports miss what's happening on site
There's some nuance to maintenance reporting because it never tells the whole story. A simple leaking faucet may turn into a full replacement of the sink cabinet if the leak was running back into the cabinet, and the work orders on the summary or even the detail pages don't always capture that.
That's why outside property surveys are valuable for operators. They get fresh eyes on the things they don't have the background to know. Our construction and management background helps us shine a light on mishaps on site where a standard asset manager might not know to even look.
See our multifamily consulting services
Related: AI fatigue in leasing, and why a person should be first touch
Common questions
What maintenance metrics should an apartment property track?
The usual set is close rate, open work orders, time to complete, overdue make readies, average days to make ready, and resident satisfaction. James Williamson, Managing Principal at Blue Brick Partners, puts time to first contact, first-time fix rate, and repeat work orders grouped by category ahead of time to complete.
Why is time to first contact a better metric than time to complete?
Residents often schedule work around their own day or their pets, so time to complete is partly outside the maintenance team's control. Time to first contact is something the team controls, which makes it a fairer first measure of responsiveness.
Does maintenance affect lease renewals?
In AppFolio's 2026 Renter Preferences Report, 56 percent of residents satisfied with maintenance planned to renew, compared with 31 percent of residents who weren't satisfied. Satisfied residents were also far more likely to recommend their property manager, 83 percent versus 28 percent.
Sources
- AppFolio: 2026 Renter Preferences Report (survey of 3,002 U.S. renters, January 26 to February 4, 2026)
- AppFolio: Happy Renters, Better Performance (press release, April 24, 2026)
This article reflects the personal views of James Williamson and the views of Blue Brick Partners. It does not represent the views of any other company.